Linda Aronson
Connect With Linda
  • Home
  • Linda's Work
    • More endorsements
    • Author >
      • 21st Century Screenplay
      • Screenwriting Updated
      • Television Writing
      • Writing With Imagination
      • Script Mechanics
    • Screenwriter
    • Plays >
      • Dinkum Assorted
      • Reginka's Lesson
      • A Night with Robinson Crusoe
      • Miss Bilbey
    • Novels
  • COURSES
  • Practical Writing Advice
    • What Type of Parallel Narrative Suit My Story
    • Parallel Narrative
    • Six Types of Parallel Narrative
    • Should I use conventional three act structure?
    • Characters in Search of a Plot
    • Double Narrative Flashback
    • Reminders about Parallel Narrative
  • Consultant, Teacher
    • Consultancy
    • Teacher & Mentor >
      • Mentorships >
        • Mentorship FAQ
      • Teaching
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Shop
  • Home
  • Linda's Work

Flashback turns your film into a detective story

3/10/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture
The English Patient
Further to my discussion with Melisha, she ended up deciding to read my book. So here's my response to her comment on that in case it might be of interest to people in Melisha's situation.  Note that when I say that flashback turns your film into a detective story, I'm not talking about the simple form of flashback, that is: 'where were you on Tuesday night?'  'Well, I was...' (go to flashback).  That's not structural, it's just dramatised backstory. I'm talking about the more complex kinds. 
It's important to realise that flashback isn't the same in all its forms. It's not just one thing.  It's six main types.   Some of the six require a complex  structure of their own, quite different from the conventional three act linear structure,  a massive scaffolding (these are the double narrative types, where you jump back and forth).  Others, like 'where were you on Tuesday night' (a type I call 'flashback as illustration) are not structural, they're just, as I say, dramatised backstory that won't affect your linear three act structure. Your job there is just to be consistent.

My answer to Melisha
Oh thanks, Melisha. I hope it's useful for you. If you don't mind me suggesting this, be sure to read the material in the book on conventional narrative first, because you need to get your head around my take on the three act structure since the way good flashback structures work is that you jump on precise points in stories that are actually three act structures in themselves, A lot of people reading my books just jump straight to the flashback chapters and then get in a mess. Unfortunately, you need to hasten slowly with this stuff.
The reason is that there are many kinds of flashback and many odd things about it. It requires a different mindset from conventional narrative. For example, in certain complex forms of flashback, the ones where you have an ongoing story in the past and an ongoing story in the present, a character can be a protagonist in one time frame (that is, seen from the inside) but an antagonist in another time frame (that is, seen from the outside by another person who is the protagonist in that time frame). It's a bit of head spinner at first, but it's to do with the fact that good flashback structures turn your film into a detective story and that requires you to create characters who are mysterious because seen from the outside in one of the time frames. So don't think of flashback just as a way to stick in a slab of backstory. Think ' a detective story about human motives'. My motto for complex flashback is 'the story in the present is a mystery story and each flashback is another clue'. That energises it. Otherwise you're just doing windshield wipers, back and forth, back and forth.
Enough!

0 Comments

Starting an adaptation movie with a flashback

3/10/2013

3 Comments

 
Picture
Slumdog Millionaire
I'm not sure whether people will be interested in this discussion on Linked In Screenwriting Discussion Group about flashback.  I've just contributed to it. I think the writer might have a hybrid flashback form on her hands, actually. 
Here's the situation.  The writer, Melisha, is having problems with flashback.  Check out the full discussion on Linked In. I joined the discussion quite late, so I'm just providing Melisha's comments to to others, and then my answer. People are urging caution and some are advising against flashback. 

MELISHA ORIGINAL QUESTION:  Ok so I'm a bit torn. I am working on an adaptation of my own book and the book has a critical flashback scene. Should I open with the flashback scene or leave it to tantalize the audience in Act 2? I know some movies start with the flashback as the opening scene but I think this may make my opening scene last longer than 15 minutes and furthermore the flashback is not the point of the script. What do you all think? This adaptation is killing me.
MELISHA RESPONSE 1 :      I will approach the script with caution. It is indeed a difficult script to prepare but I'm learning a lot as I go. Do you remember the movie Premonition with Sandra Bullock? I thought this was a good movie that used tons of flashback to tell the story but I was confused the entire time. I don't want to confuse the audience too much but I do have to make these transitions to help the audience understand the antagonist's reason for "stalking" the protagonist. And yes you are right, it was a few centuries ago when they met but only the antagonist is aware of this because he's been living for many centuries.

 MELISHA RESPONSE 2: Well this particular flashback is a big piece of the puzzle in the story but it is the subplot so I'm thinking I will add it around the end of Act 2.

MELISHA RESPONSE 3: Let me further break down my dilimma. I have two main characters who met in the past and its a sort of deja vu thing. The storyline is in the present but I have to flashback twice to introduce the audience to the historical characters. So I opened with the antagonist because his story is important but not as important as the one of the protagonist. His flashback is minimal - about 15 minutes and will have a narrator in the background. Her flashback is the subplot and critical to understanding what is going on in the present so I want to place her in Act 2. I don't know if I should open with his flashback or open in the present and somehow squeeze his debut in somehow like as a character is thinking about something then it changes scenes to the character's thoughts.

LINDA's ANSWER
Unfortunately I haven't seen Premonition, so I can't comment on that. However, I might be able to help you in structuring your film. As a writer who could never find any answers about flashback I wrote first one then another book on how to structure a whole family of different types of flashback, also how to structure other types of nonlinear film (for example, Pulp Fiction). The latest book (which is more up to date) is called The 21st Century Screeenplay and it's published by Silman James. It's required reading at NYU and Berkeley and lots of other film schools around the world, as well as being used by professionals, so a lot of people are finding it useful so maybe you will too.

The good news is that successful flashback films work to clear patterns, based on jumping between past and present in very specific ways at very specific points in the three act structure. In a nutshell, they jump on cliffhangers, but very specific cliffhangers and you must get these right or you'll send the audience in completely the wrong direction. The patterns are so clear that you can use them as templates.
There are actually quite a few different types of flashback, each structured differently, so you need to work out which suits your purpose. The rule is content dictates structure. For example, Slumdog Millionaire jumps back and forth between past and present with a storyline in each, whereas Goodfellas starts in the middle of the film with a crucial scene, then jumps back to the start and continues straight through from beginning to end with no more flashbacks. And there's another kind of flashback that I call a 'Life Changing Incident ' flashback, which is an incremental flashback - that is, one crucial event revealed bit by bit- as in Twelve Monkeys or Catch 22. And so on. As I say, each of these types is structured in a different way, with the jumps occurring at different times in each.
Yes, you could indeed simply tell the past through exposition, but think of Slumdog Millionaire without the flashbacks, all told through dialogue in the present. It wouldn't be half as vivid.
It's hard to comment on how precisely you should structure your film. It could feel very jerky if you open on one character, follow it for fifteen minutes, then switch to another. It may well feel as if we're in another film. My feeling is that your most likely bet is to start in the present at the second act turning point - then jump back to the disturbance of the story in the past. That's how many of these films start. That way, you should avoid the start-stop effect. But I could be wrong here. You may need to start elsewhere. You might need a different structure to suit your purpose. I stress this stuff isn't easy. . I've got some advice on my website www.lindaaronson.com but try to get hold of a copy of one of my books (they're in lots of libraries) because there are all kinds of ways to get in a mess with flashback. Good luck


3 Comments

    RSS Feed

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Author

    Linda is a screenwriter, novelist and playwright. As well as teaching and mentoring writers around the world, she regularly consults on screenplays at the highest level in the US, UK and Australia.

    Picture

    Subscribe to Linda Aronson's Craft Skills Newsletter

    Archives

    June 2017
    May 2017
    September 2015
    June 2015
    September 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011

    Categories

    All
    Advice For Actors
    Advice For New Writers
    Advice For New Writers
    Advice For Writers
    Advice For Writers
    Agent
    Brainstorm
    Brainstorming
    Cell Phone Movie
    Characters
    Christopher Vogler
    Cliche
    Creating A Storyline
    Creating A Storyline
    Difference Between Film And Fiction Writing
    Dinkum Assorted
    Double Journey
    Double Journey
    Double Narrative Flashback
    Double Narrative Flashback
    First Act Turning Point
    Flashback
    Flashback As Detective Story
    Games Writing
    Getting Ideas
    Getting Into Film And Tv
    Ghost
    Hero's Journey
    Lateral Imagination
    Linda Aronson
    Linear
    Magnificent Seven
    Motivation
    Multiple Protagonist
    Multiple Protagonist Films
    Multi Protagonist
    Multi Protagonist
    Multi Protagonist
    Multi-protagonist
    Mystery
    New Writer
    Nonlinear
    Non Linear
    Non Linear
    Parallel Narrative General
    Pay It Forward
    Pitching
    Radio Writing
    Scriptwriting Software
    Shakespeare
    Short Film
    Sitcom
    Slumdog Millionaire
    Tandem Narrative
    The Great Gatsby
    The Hangover
    Three Act Structure
    Three Act Structure
    Thriller
    Tootsie
    Tv Series And Mini Serials
    Tv Writing
    Vertical Imagination
    Women Characters
    Writing Dialogue
    Writing Fiction

    Note: Hi everyone. For RSS feed from this blog, you'll need feedly.com or theoldreader.com. Thanks, Linda

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.